Combining Multiple UK Pensions Into One International Plan: Is It Worth It?

The Challenge of Multiple UK Pensions for Expats

Many British expats find themselves juggling three, four, or even more workplace pension schemes accumulated throughout their UK careers. Each scheme comes with its own annual statements, different providers, varying fee structures, and distinct investment options. For someone living in France, Spain, or elsewhere in Europe, managing this pension portfolio becomes increasingly complex.

The question many expats face is whether to consolidate these multiple UK pensions into a single international Self-Invested Personal Pension (SIPP). The answer depends on your specific circumstances, but understanding the potential benefits and drawbacks can help you make an informed decision.

Benefits of Pension Consolidation for Expats

Simplified Administration

Managing one pension statement instead of several reduces administrative burden significantly. You'll receive a single annual statement, deal with one provider, and have a clearer picture of your total retirement wealth. This becomes particularly valuable when you're navigating French or Spanish tax reporting requirements, where each pension scheme may need separate declaration.

Reduced Annual Management Charges

Many workplace pension schemes charge annual management fees of 0.5% to 1.5% per year. Smaller pension pots often face higher percentage charges due to fixed administration costs. By consolidating into a larger international SIPP, you may access institutional-grade investment options with lower ongoing charges, potentially saving hundreds or thousands of pounds annually.

Enhanced Investment Choice

Workplace pensions typically offer limited investment funds chosen by your former employer. An international SIPP provides access to thousands of investment options, including individual shares, bonds, commercial property, and offshore investment bonds. This flexibility becomes crucial for expats who want currency diversification or investments that align with their new country of residence.

Currency Flexibility

International SIPPs can hold multiple currencies, allowing you to match your pension investments to your spending currency. If you're permanently settled in France and spending euros, you can gradually shift your pension investments to euro-denominated assets, reducing currency risk in retirement.

Potential Drawbacks to Consider

Loss of Guaranteed Benefits

Some older workplace pension schemes offer guaranteed annuity rates or final salary benefits that could be worth significantly more than the current transfer value. Before consolidating, obtain a transfer value statement and consider whether you're giving up valuable guarantees. Final salary schemes, in particular, rarely make sense to transfer unless your circumstances are exceptional.

Transfer Costs and Exit Penalties

Some pension providers charge exit fees for transfers, typically ranging from £100 to £500 per scheme. Additionally, if your current pension investments have performed well recently, you might face market value reductions when transferring. Factor these costs into your consolidation decision.

Regulatory Protections

UK workplace pensions benefit from the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) protection up to £85,000 per provider. International SIPPs may have different compensation arrangements, though reputable providers typically offer equivalent or superior protection through segregated client assets and professional indemnity insurance.

Tax Implications for Expats

The tax treatment of pension transfers varies significantly depending on your country of residence. For British expats in France, pension transfers between UK schemes generally don't trigger immediate tax charges. However, the ongoing tax treatment of your consolidated pension may differ.

French tax residents must declare their worldwide pension income, but the UK-France double taxation treaty typically ensures you're not taxed twice on the same income. An international SIPP may offer more flexibility in managing when and how you take pension income, potentially optimising your French tax position.

In Spain, similar principles apply, though Spanish wealth tax considerations may influence your decision. The ability to hold investments in different currencies within an international SIPP can help manage both income tax and wealth tax obligations.

When Consolidation Makes Sense

Pension consolidation typically works best when you have multiple smaller pension pots (under £30,000 each), high annual charges on existing schemes, or limited investment options that don't suit your expat circumstances. It's also valuable if you're struggling to keep track of multiple providers or want to implement a coordinated investment strategy.

However, avoid rushing into consolidation. Take time to review each scheme's benefits, charges, and investment performance. Consider seeking advice from a specialist who understands both UK pension rules and the tax implications in your country of residence.

How We Can Help

International Wealth Ventures can assess whether transferring your UK pensions to an international SIPP makes sense for your situation — evaluating costs, benefits, and tax implications in your country of residence. Our pension specialists understand the complexities facing British expats and can help you navigate the transfer process while ensuring you don't lose valuable benefits. Get a free pension review to discuss your consolidation options and create a strategy that works for your expat lifestyle.

---

About the Author

Christopher Brown — Financial Journalist — Expat France. Christopher is a financial journalist covering British expat life in France. He writes about French tax residency, assurance vie, UK pension transfers, and inheritance planning under French law.